Printer friendly version |  E-mail to a friend 
| Text Size: A A A A |
Bookmark and Share
 
Published Monday, June 15, 2009 6:05 AM

Meddling at the top threatens A&M's future

Sunday's resignation by Texas A&M University President Elsa Murano shows just what a mess Gov. Rick Perry, Chancellor Mike McKinney and the A&M System Board of Regents have made of things. They have totally mishandled the running of the university and, in doing so, have threatened the many advances it has made in recent years toward becoming a first-class university.

In the process, Murano was treated shabbily and left dangling, waiting to be dismissed or to resign. With regents apparently planning to fire her on Monday, she took the graceful and dignified way out and, in doing so, gave those in charge of the system a golden opportunity to fix some of the myriad of problems they have created.

For the good of Texas A&M and, indeed, the entire state, we hope they do so.

The first step is for McKinney to appoint a committee of A&M faculty members to conduct a legitimate nationwide search for a new A&M president. It must have clear parameters and direction and it must be free from interference by the governor, the regents or the system administration.

The search must be thorough and exhaustive, making sure the next president has the ability, interest and desire to do what is best for A&M, the university.

At the same time, McKinney should clearly state that, under no circumstances, will he assume the dual role of chancellor and university president, as he indicated last month he might do. That would be a disaster for Texas A&M University and the entire A&M System. The two jobs are very, very different and no one person can effectively do both, as Jack Kenny Williams painfully learned more than 30 years ago.

At the same time, McKinney should clearly state that, under no circumstances, will he assume the dual role of chancellor and university president, as he indicated last month he might do. That would be a disaster for Texas A&M University and the entire A&M System. The two jobs are very, very different and no one person can effectively do both, as Jack Kenny Williams painfully learned more than 30 years ago.

Further, McKinney has so alienated himself from the faculty and staff of the university with his heavy-handed fumbling of the current situation that he would have no governing credibility whatsoever.

Gov. Perry must also assure the A&M System, the university and all the people of Texas that under no circumstances would he as-sume the chancellorship of the system, as has been rumored far and wide for several months. It may be his dream job and he might not want to face U.S. Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison in the March Republican primary, but he must keep his hands off the A&M System.

Texas A&M belongs to the people of Texas. It should not be treated as the personal sandbox of any politician.

Once the search committee has been allowed to do its job, regents must give the person it recommends every due consideration. They should resist the temptation to go outside the list of candidates considered by the committee to name a president, as they did with Murano.

Murano obviously wasn't given enough time to settle into her role as president. No doubt, she made mistakes along the way, but she seemed to be doing better and, had McKinney and the regents left her alone, she could have become a fine president.

She started off badly by firing A&M Vice President for Student Affairs Dean Bresciani and naming Perry friend and Aggie classmate Joseph F. Weber -- the retired commander of the U.S. Marine Corps Forces Command -- to replace him. Later, though, she bucked the governor and chancellor by following the recommendation of a university search committee that included faculty, students and staff to name Jeffrey Seemann, a dean at the University of Rhode Island, as A&M's vice president for research -- apparently against the wishes of Perry and McKinney.

The turmoil of the past several months has hurt A&M's ability to recruit qualified administrators and faculty, and, A&M researchers say, has hurt the ability of the university to attract grants and other funding. It also could affect the generous financial support for which former students are known.

The chancellor is supposed to represent and serve all components of the A&M System. As it is, many of the universities in the system feel slighted and left out. Having the chancellor assume the presidency of the premier university in the system would further distance them from the system. It simply must not happen.

Texas is blessed to have two outstanding university systems that rank among the best in the nation. It would be devastating for one of them to lose that status because of meddling at the very top.




Notice about comments: Theeagle.com is pleased to offer readers the ability to comment on stories. We expect our readers to engage in lively, yet civil discourse. Theeagle.com cannot promise that readers will not occasionally find offensive or inaccurate comments posted in the comments area. Responsibility for the statements posted lies with the person submitting the comment, not theeagle.com. If you find a comment that is objectionable, please click "report abuse" and we will review it for possible removal. Please be reminded, however, that in accordance with our Terms of Use and federal law, we are under no obligation to remove any third party comments posted on our website. Full terms and conditions can be read here. The Eagle is proud to offer our users enhanced commenting features. You can now build user-to-user connections, follow friend's recent posts, add an avatar that fits your personality, and more. If you have posted here before you’ll need to sign up again and if you’ve never posted start now by signing up!

Comments
5 comment(s) found!


Posted by: On: Thursday, June 18, 2009 12:05 PM

Comment Title: Change the A&M System!
First, I believe that Chancellor McKinney running both the A&M System and A&M is crazy. I am very concerned about the direction that the A&M System is heading. President Murano was not given enough time to produce a successful run as our leader. I also support the idea of the A&M System schools having their own identity, yet remaining members of the A&M System, much like Tarleton State, Prarie View and West Texas. Recently, the Javelina Alumni of Kingsville pushed to get their name back as it was from 1928-1994 when it was Texas A&I University. Unfortunately, the legislative session ended right before being voted out of the House for Gov. Perry's signature. Like most Aggies, I believe there is only 1 true A&M and that's in College Station. The other A&M System schools are not (truly) A&M, they are simply a part of our system. Let them have their own identity just as we are proud of our unique name, mascot, history and traditions. Gig 'em!
Report Abuse
Posted by: Lu Worsham On: Tuesday, June 16, 2009 1:44 PM

Comment Title: Perception is Everything
To most outsiders, perception is certainly the first thing and likely everything. Chancellor McKinney has, at the least, embarassed A&M and many of its former students. He has hurt the university in ways not yet apparent. When politics and ego superceed professionalism and integrity this sort of mess can occur....and it has. You have shamed us nationally, Dr. Mckinney. Step down now !
Report Abuse
Posted by: George55 On: Monday, June 15, 2009 5:32 PM

Comment Title: First Things First
Completely agree that Dr. McKinney should resign. His actions have brought shame to the Aggie family and have tarnished the reputation of the university. If he has any integrity at all, if he cares for the university, the university system, and the state of Texas, he must step down.
Report Abuse
Posted by: On: Monday, June 15, 2009 1:21 PM

Comment Title: What do we expect ?
Rick Perry's limited competence and grand ambition are a bad combination, particularly when he has the power to appoint political hacks like McKinney and Don McLeroy to influential positions. People who voted for him probably love the results they're seeing, but the other 61 percent are justifiably shrugging and waiting for Perry to be sent on his way.
Report Abuse
Posted by: On: Monday, June 15, 2009 11:00 AM

Comment Title: The first step
I respectfully disagree. The first step for A&M to recover is for Chancellor McKinney to submit his resignation.
Report Abuse

 
The Eagle's Most Popular
  • Commented
  • Emailed
  • Viewed

    Top Ads
    • Jobs
    • Cars
    • Homes
    • Merchandise
    Straw Poll

    © 2010 The Bryan College Station Eagle
    Contact Us | Subscribe/Customer Care | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | FAQ | Corrections | RSS Feeds | E-mail News